Fishing Spoons vs Spinners: How to Build a Metal Lure Range for Trout, Pike and Salmon

Short answer: spoons and spinners catch the same predators but sell to slightly different anglers. Spoons are simple, cast far and work at any depth; spinners give constant flash and vibration on a slow retrieve and are the first lure many trout anglers buy. A balanced metal lure range has casting spoons, a few classic wobbling spoons, inline spinners in three or four blade sizes, and a heavier line for salmon and pike.

Spoons and spinners compared
| Spoons | Inline spinners | |
|---|---|---|
| How they work | Curved metal blade wobbles and flutters | Blade spins around a wire shaft in front of a body |
| Best retrieve | Any speed; also jigging on the drop | Steady, slow to medium retrieve |
| Casting distance | Very long | Medium |
| Main species | Trout, salmon, pike, perch, sea bass, mackerel | Trout, salmon, steelhead, pike, perch, panfish |
| Common weights | 2 g to 60 g | 2 g to 30 g |
Spoon shapes
- Long slim spoons cast far and flutter on the drop; good for shore fishing and mackerel.
- Teardrop and willow spoons are the classic wobbling spoon for trout, pike and perch.
- Area trout spoons are small (1.5 to 5 g) and sold in many bright two-tone colors.
- Hammered zinc spoons are die-cast with deep 3D patterns for extra flash.
- Trolling and flutter spoons are thin and wide for slow trolling behind boats.
Spinner blades
| Blade | Action | Use |
|---|---|---|
| French / round | Wide angle, strong vibration | Slow water, stained water, trout and perch |
| Willow | Tight angle, more flash, less pull | Faster water and faster retrieves |
| Colorado | Very strong thump | Dirty water and night fishing |
| Tandem / double | More flash and noise | Pike and bass |
Finishes and hooks
Silver, gold and copper plating are still the best sellers. Add black nickel, holographic, glow and painted blades for variety. Spoons come with treble hooks, single hooks (often required in catch-and-release waters) or feathered trebles; spinners often have dressed trebles with feathers, tinsel or bucktail.
Planning a range
- Pick 3 to 5 shapes and offer each in 3 to 4 weights.
- Choose 6 to 10 core colors that work everywhere, then add local favorites.
- Use one card design for all metal lures so the shop display looks like one brand.
- Keep one approved sample of each item for reorders.
FAQ
Can you make spoons in weights that are not in your catalog?
Yes. Most series can be made in other weights from the same blade design, and we make new blades to your drawing.
Can spinners be made with single hooks?
Yes. Single, barbless and treble hooks are all available.
What packaging do you offer for spoons and spinners?
Blister cards, plastic boxes and bulk bags, printed with your logo and barcode.